Thursday, October 4, 2007

Unpublished: Willie Will review

Here's an older review that got sacked before it could see the light of day. Enjoy.


Photo Sharing and Video Hosting at Photobucket

The kid’s got heart. He’s got concepts. There’s a well-known and talented producer behind the boards. There’s depth to his lyrics.

But listening to Willie Will’s major label debut, Reflection, there still seems to be some sort of disconnect.

I mean, I liked Will’s cameo on Soul P’s “Do My Thang” and we’ve heard him sound nice on the Best of the Submissions mixtapes…. but I’m simply not “wowed!”

That’s not to say there isn’t any quality work here though. “Say So”, in particular, caught me in the second round with its clever, two-fisted hook:

Let the redeemed of the Lord say so / “So!”
If you’ve been redeemed by the Lord say so / “So!”
Let it show / put your fist in the air and say /“So!”

Which later turns into:

Man, I used to see you in the club… / “So?!?”
Man, I used to see you smokin’ bud… / “So?!?”
Man, I used to see you with them thugs… / “So?!?”
Man, you was with them chicks gettin’ love… / Man…“So?!?”

In truth, that’s actually one of the dopest turns of phrase I’ve heard in a while.

And “Blame Game” does a cool perspective shift in each verse where Will narrates the story of finger-pointing Christians named Johnny, Donny, and Ronnie. Again, you may not catch it on the first listen, but as you give it a second or third spin the pieces of the puzzle come together to create a cool little portrait.

I was also impressed at the honesty and storytelling of “Help Me” where Willie Will admits his fight against Flesh to lend tangible aid to those in his immediate vicinity who are suffering. In this song you get several snapshots with poignant details that paint a clear picture of the scene and situation.

Photo Sharing and Video Hosting at Photobucket

So that’s at least three check marks in the “Plus” column right?

Maybe it was the over polished production. Todd Collins has been known to make some nice beats and guide a project to success with equal amounts of commercial and street acumen. (See Soul P’s “The Premiere.”)

But most of the backbeats here just fall flat. The only real heat is found in “Move Somethin’” and “Say So.”

And if those are the head nodders, the head scratcher may be the indiscernible chorus of “All For You.”

This track is very similar to Knine’s “For You” in that it tells the Easter story from the perspective of the Crucified Savior. Unfortunately, in this version you can’t tell what the words are in the hook.

Is he saying “It’s God baby?”, “It’s all baby?”, or “It’s on baby?”

It’s the most powerful story in the world and yet the muddy loop leaves the listener in the dark. Quite puzzling indeed.

Perhaps my ambivalence toward this record is that whenever there’s a featured performance (Soul P on “We Don’t Back Down” and k-Drama on “Shine”) I’m more drawn to the guest’s verse than Will’s.

It could also be that on a song like “No” Willie Will sounds like a right-wing Republican hitting all the key platform issues of gay marriage, school prayer, and keeping the word “God” on our currency and in our national pledge.

It’s not that I think these items aren’t worthy of discussion or exploration. It’s just that they seem

1) out of place on this album,
2) like talking points from the “No Spin Zone”, and
3) like it’s a calculated attempt to reach a target demographic.

So, what’s the final grade? I have to conclude that it’s an unbalanced sum of highs and lows that make it an average contribution to the Beatmart catalog.

Willie Will has both talent and potential. It’s just not reflected in great portion here.


Video for "Shine"

1 comment:

Jnorm888 said...

I disagree with you. I think "Reflections" is a classic.

The song "all for you" is one of my favorite songs on the album. I see that you don't like "EASTCOAST" BEATS. The two songs you liked (Let the redeemed of the Lord say so, and move something) were the two I wasn't feeling to much.

The video "shine" was what made me buy the album. I thought the beat to that song was hot as well as the content, and lyrics. I like the version on the video better because that last verse made alot of sense.

And that song called "no" didn't seem out of place to me. Well, I didn't like the beat too much, but Willie Will did a song similar to that one in a previous album. So that is part of who Willie Will is.

To say that he was trying to please a certain demographic is unfair. If that is who you are. And if that is what you believe then how can you say that he was doing it to please people?

But anyway. The album was hot. The production wasn't really all that good. But it was decent.

I think Willie Will was being honest on this album....just like he was in his past albums.